Essential Information on an Essential Issue
15 August, 1999
- STATISTICS THAT MATTER
Figures for the June Quarter 99
- TRANZ RAIL JOB LOSSES
Tranz Rail is expected to cut hundreds more staff, after already making 480 staff
redundant in the last year. This means Tranz Rail will have made nearly a third of its staff redundant in
a two-year period. The company says the job cuts will be "across the board" and it has also put
a hold on all new capital expenditure, although ruling out the closure or sale any of its businesses.
Tranz Rail says it has been forced into more lay-offs because its profit and revenue results
continue to be disappointing. Profits for the company were up 46% percent to $70m for the year,
but this was inflated by a one-off tax credit of $57.3m.
Last year the 480 redundancies cost the company $18.9m equal to an average payout
of $39,000 per former worker. Tranz Rail has just announced a $15.5m contingency for lay-offs
this year, which at last year's average payout would indicate the company is looking at cutting
Tranz Rail is controlled by a consortium of Fay Richwhite, Wisconsin Central and the
Berkshire Fund, which bought the company from the government in 1993.
- Railway worker unions warn that the company should expect considerable resistance
to more layoffs, especially after the high annual profit announcement. Rail union secretary
Ross Wilson says that unless there was another economic downturn, Tranz Rail would need
every worker it had. Wilson: "We wouldn't expect there to be much more room for staff reductions
on current tonnages ... and we will need to look at any further layoffs to see if they affect the
health and safety of the remaining staff."
Sources The Evening Post 4 August 1999 "Tranz Rail slashing Jobs" by Dean Bedford; The Dominion 4 August
1999 "Tranz Rail to shed more staff" by James Wier
- RESTRUCTURING TO CLOSE THREE MEATWORKS
Hawkes Bay meat processor Richmond is to centralise most of its specialised lamb
processing at a new $14m plant at Takapau, south of Hastings. The move will see the closure of
three meat works the Omahu Road and the Food Processors plants in Napier, and the Awatoto
plant (which will be mothballed). The move will affect the jobs of 584 people, although 390 "new"
jobs will be available in the new Takapau works.
The Richmond company had acquired Lowe Walker nearly two years ago, which saw its
network of plants in the region increase from three to seven. The company says that recent declines
in stock numbers played a major part in reducing the efficiency of its network of processing
Source The Dominion 4 August 1999 "Meatworks restructuring cuts 90 jobs" by NZPA; 5 August 1999 "Economy
still strong despite works closures" by NZPA
DAIRY JOB LOSSES LOOM
The Dairy Workers Union says that, if the merger of the Dairy Board and several dairy
co-operative companies goes ahead, it will accelerate the job losses expected in the dairy
industry. Union secretary Ray Potroz says that 500 job losses are expected by the industry as
technology replaces people and manufacturing plants are further rationalised. Potroz says the ax is
currently being held over the heads of dairy factory workers in Kaikoura, Northland, Morrinsville,
Golden Bay and Te Awamutu.
Source The Dominion, 20 July 1999 "Nearly 500 dairy plant workers likely to lose jobs"
- HBL LOST TO WANGANUI
Wanganui is reeling from the news that 160 jobs are going as a major government
agency, Health Benefits Limited (HBL), is relocating to Wellington. HBL pays prescription subsidies
to pharmacists and health professionals, and the agency is one of Wanganui's largest employers.
The General Manager of HBL, Tony White, says the shift is due to extensive re-organisation as
claims processing becomes increasingly electronic. The agency has already closed branch offices
in Auckland and Christchurch, and operations will now be centralised on the Wellington
office. Staffing will eventually be cut from 300 to 100 people.
The Labour MP for Wanganui, Jill Pettis, is asking the auditor General to investigate the
HBL move. The potential loss of the agency and its $9m contribution to the Wanganui economy
has been a simmering political issue in the town for some years.
Source Checkpoint National Radio item 3 August 1999, report by Stephen Harris
- LIGHTS OUT
Zelma, the only light bulb manufacturer in NZ, announces it can no longer compete
with Asian products and will close its Miramar plant. General manager Mike Gill has announced
that 70 staff will lose their jobs as the 59-year old company closes its doors. Much of Zelma's
products were exported to Australia and South Africa.
Source Dominion, 15/7/99, Factory lights out after 59 years
- BRUTAL NEWS FOR 122 POWER WORKERS
The Power company Hawkes Bay Network is also restructuring, to "concentrate on
core activities", and will cut staff from about 200 to 78 people. The company does expect some staff
to get future employment with the independent contractors who will pick up the maintenance
contracts on the line system.
The media has reported that the power company staff were upset at the way general
manager Malcolm Walker announced the job losses at meetings in Napier and Hastings. At one
meeting, according to The Dominion, sixty field staff were crammed into a room and 17 names were
read out the names of the staff to be retained. As each name was read, the person had to stand
up and leave the room. Many staff were in tears, and others complained that the experience
was embarrassing, inhumane and lacked compassion.
Source The Dominion 6 August 1999 "Job-loss news broken brutally, staff complain" by NZPA
- UNEMPLOYMENT DECLINES SLIGHTLY
The latest Household Labour Force Survey shows that the growth of employment
has stalled, unemployment has declined slightly, and there has been an increase in the numbers
of people "not in the labour force". We include our regular
Statistics That Matter summary as a insert in this issue of
The Jobs Letter.
- The official unemployment numbers stood at 131,000 people for the June quarter, with
the unemployment rate now 7%, compared to 7.2% three months ago, and 7.6% a year ago.
The average OECD unemployment rate is 6.8%. The employment numbers have remained steady
at 1.74 million, the same as in the March quarter, but 21,000 higher than at June last year.
- Also in the figures:
The drop in unemployment (3,000 people) is almost entirely accounted for by a rise in
the numbers of people classified as "not in the labour force", rather than people who have got a job.
- Women accounted for 18,000 of the 21,000 new jobs in the last year
Three-quarters of the new jobs were in part-time work.
Three sectors have had significant shifts in employment: services and sales worker
numbers rose 17,800 in the past year; agriculture and fisheries numbers rose 16,800; machine
operation and assembly worker numbers declined by 11,800.
Fewer young workers are in paid work, with the number of people 20-24 years old
in employment falling 11,700 in the last year.
Maori unemployment remains high at 18.2%, compared to 12.8% for Pacific Islanders
and 5.1% for Europeans.
Sources Statistics from Statistics NZ; The Dominion 6 August 1999 "unemployment declines slightly"; The Daily News
6 August 1999 "Unemployment rate falls" by NZPA; New Zealand Herald 6 August 1999 "Growth in job market stalls" by
Brian Fallow; newsroom press releases from political parties from www.newsroom.co.nz
- VOICES:ON THE LATEST JOBS FIGURES
"The continuing fall in unemployment reflects the return to economic growth in the last
year. After being hit hard by the rural drought and the Asian crisis, the economy is rebounding and
we have seen growth all year. That's feeding through into more jobs, and it will continue.
"We hear regular claims that "there are no jobs", which is clearly nonsense. There are one
and three quarter million people in work, and tens of thousands of jobs change hands each year.
New Zealand forecasters are predicting growth of around 30,000 new jobs in the year to March
2000. These forecasts, and today's figures, should give New Zealanders confidence in the future ..."
Peter McCardle, Minister of Work and Income
"The figures are a reality check. The employment outturn suggests that businesses are not
convinced about the robustness of the economic recovery..."
Bevan Graham, Westpac chief economist
"Do not be fooled. This is another Clayton's improvement. The fall in the unemployment
rate from the March quarter was due entirely to the shift of people from inside the labour force
to outside the labour force. That is all..."
Bancorp economists, quoted in The
"We are looking at a steady trend into part-time work when people are crying out for
full-time jobs and proper incomes. New Zealand is not producing the secure, quality jobs needed in
vital sectors. It will end up as a theme park with nothing but service jobs unless we get a
government prepared to invest in education, research and business growth ..."
Steve Maharey, Labour employment spokesman
"The government's policy of destroying the viability of the regions while at the same time
destroying thousands of jobs through tariff removal is ripping the heart out of New Zealand.
This government has no strategies for dealing with unemployment. They are quite content to
claim victory at such small fluctuations in unemployment while they allow the Reserve Bank to
keep unemployment at around 6-7% permanently..."
Jim Anderton, Leader of The Alliance
- COMMUNITY BANKING
Since 1993, 555 bank branches (or a total of 36%) have closed across New Zealand.
A "Community Banking" forum, addressing the economic impact of the loss of these banking
services to rural and suburban New Zealand, was held in Wellington last week. The forum,
convened by the Commonwealth development organisation Commact, heard many stories of how
rural communities have been reduced to "ghost towns" after their last local bank closed. The
main reason: when people drove to larger centres to do their banking, they usually did their
shopping there as well.
Australian Commact leader Peter Kenyon quotes research that when the last bank closes in
a town, annual turnover in other businesses also slumps by about 25-40%. His figures show
that when a local bank closes, transactions worth $350/person per month also leave the area.
- Northland businessman Tony Shicker told the "Community Banking" forum how the
tiny community of Maungaturoto recently held a public meeting and formed their own
storefront "money exchange" in order to keep banking services in the district. They faced an uphill
battle: when the last bank closed its doors two months ago, the bank sent in a demolition team to
smash up fixtures with sledge-hammers, and remove the carpets, so that nothing could be re-used.
- The Commact forum featured Russell Jenkins from the Bendigo Bank in Victoria,
Australia a bank which is proving to be a world leader in bringing financial services back to
Over the last year the Bendigo Bank has been offering franchise partnerships to "bankless"
communities, and has been overwhelmed with the response. Dozens of Australian rural and
suburban communities are presently working with Bendigo to set up their own community banks.
The Bendigo partnership model involves the community creating a trust which attracts
hundreds of local investors to become the shareholders in their own local bank. The trust operates
under the co-operative principles of "one person one vote", regardless of how many shares that
person might own.
The trust does a business plan and establishes the local storefront bank, buying the equipment
and hiring and paying staff. The Bendigo Bank provides the use of its banking license, protects
all deposits, and offers the full range of services including loans, investments, superannuation,
All profits are split 50-50 between the bank and the local community. Russell Jenkins
reported that the first community banks established just a year ago in the small Victorian communities
of Minyip and Rupanyup are already turning a profit.
Jenkins: "If the local people are owners of their own bank, then they are much more likely
to support it. We are finding that we are getting more than twice the normal market-share of
the local business using this franchise model ... which is a win for us, and also a win for the
local communities which get their banking services back, and they get a share of the profits that
are generated by the business."
- Can a Bendigo community banking system happen here in New Zealand? The
Commact forum heard many stories from rural New Zealand illustrating the market potential waiting
for such a system. The sticking point is finding the right local partner, with a banking license, that
is prepared to develop our own franchise model.
Ian Reid, a former head of the Public Service Investment Society (PSIS) told the Commact
forum that the few remaining NZ-owned financial institutions PSIS, The Taranaki TSB Bank,
local building societies and credit unions are all small individually, but control total assets of
around $3 billion. Reid: "I think there is an opportunity to try and tap the existing businesses, and
that could well be brought together in some informal or formal way to provide a reasonable asset..."
The chief executive of the Southland Building Society (SBS) Ross Smith, says he has had
discussions with the TSB "to see if there is something we could do jointly". Smith: "Nothing has
come of that. That's not to say we won't talk to someone else..."
- Green MP Rod Donald last week hosted a public meeting at the Beehive theatrette
to promote the Bendigo model for local banking. He says that if the Greens are a part of the
next coalition government, he will try to bring together the NZ-owned banking institutions in order
to foster a local banking franchise. Donald: "I believe there is very definitely a crisis for
smaller communities as the big banks focus on their large corporate customers and making big
profits. The little people, the small retailers, the superannuitants and the beneficiaries are losing out in
this process ... but so is the whole wider community because the local businesses are losing turnover.
"The big banks are going to have to sit up and take notice, because these people are going to
shift their business to something like the Bendigo model. Every building society and credit union in
the country could become a branch of the TSB in a partnership arrangement ... and this would
bring banking back to the local communities."
Source Jobs Letter editor vivian Hutchinson chaired the Commact Forum held at the Airport Hotel, Wellington 3
August 1999; Checkpoint Radio NZ item 3 August 1999 by David Passey; Wellington City Voice 29 July 1999 "Plan to link
NZ financiers" by Simon Collins; Paper by Lindsay Jeffs to the Commact Conference, Wellington, 3 August 1999.
- STATISTICS THAT MATTER :
This electorate contains 22,212 households,
of which 52% have household incomes below $30,000 per year before tax. That 52% is 18%
above the rate for the country as a whole. There are 30,861 adults aged 20-59 in the Wairarapa
electorate, of whom 61% are in paid, full-time work. Another 14% are in part-time work.
Unemployment in the electorate is 2% below the national average. Localities in the Wairarapa
electorate which have high levels of deprivation are: Eketahuna and Masterton: Central, East, and
Railway. ( Electorate statistics compiled by Judy Reinken, and based on 1996 Census).
Source _ Judy Reinken, statistics based on 1996 Census of Population and Dwellings
- STUDENT LOANS LEADING TO SKILLS SHORTAGES
A company that helps match skilled information technology (IT) workers with IT jobs
says that the student loan scheme is creating a brain drain in NZ. Murray McCaw, managing
director of Comtex, says that the average IT graduate spends only 16 months working in NZ before
going overseas. At exit interviews, the graduates say it is more than the big OE or better money that
is drawing them away. A major factor in their decision to leave the country is also to avoid
repaying their student loans. McCaw says the country needs to reconsider how it is training people:
"We need to make sure that we have education directed in a manner that ensures that we're going
to reap the benefit."
Alliance education spokesperson Liz Gordon reports statistics that support the view of a
"brain drain" being caused by the student loan scheme. Students who have left the country currently
owe $100m. Gordon says that those who have left the country owe on average $3,000 more
than other students and she says this points to their motivation for leaving.
- The lack of skilled IT workers is a disincentive for high tech companies to set up in
NZ according to Howard Frederick, director of the NZ Internet Institute at Victoria
University. Frederick says that Motorola corporation has been considering setting up in NZ but the
company does not see a local skills base to support an operation here. He says Motorola could employ
400 staff but would expect to interview as many as ten times that number over four years.
Frederick says NZ just does not produce that number of people with graduate IT degrees, and he calls
on the government to provide stimulus funding to expand training in this
Sources The Dominion 30 July 1999 "Departing students owe more"; New Zealand Herald, 27 July 1999, "Loan
scheme drains brains"
- OLDER WORKERS FACE THE SQUEEZE
A Massey University lecturer predicts that many mature workers will be forced out of
full-time work by the year 2010. Professor David Thomson told an audience at Auckland
University last week that up to 40% of the mature labour force could lose their full-time work early in
the next century. Thomson: "This change in the past 20 years has been huge and relentless, it
touches all levels of society, spreads right across the developed world, and shows little sign of halting,
let alone reversing ..."
- Thomson says that, if the present trends continue, then within a decade a third of all
NZ men by their later 40s will be "retired" (without significant prospects of getting paid
work again)... and half of them by their mid-50s. For women, he expects that only 40% will have
substantial paid work in their mid-50s.
The current figures show just how deeply we are already into what Thomson describes as a
"post-work world". Until the 1970s, 96 out of every 100 men had full-time paid work from their 20s
to their early 50s ... and only then did employment levels fall off.
Using data from the census (in which full-time work is defined as 20 or more hours a
week), Thomson reports that by 1996, the proportion of men in full-time work was below 80% at
every age. It was 77% for men in their later 40s, 65% in their later 50s and 40% in their early 60s.
Thomson: "We press everyone to save for retirement, with vague threats about the shrinking
of superannuation in the future. But the advertising campaigns are built unthinkingly around
the assumption that full and unbroken employment will last until age 65..."
- Thomson reports that more and more of the work done after age 45 is in self
employment and much of this is uncertain, insecure and low-paying. Twenty years ago, 75% of men
aged 50-54, for example, received wages or salaries for full-time work, and 20% were
self-employed. By 1996, just 50% had wages or salaries for 20 or more hours a week, and 27% were
self-employed. The rest included some part-timers, but Thomson says most were simply without work.
Thomson: "If large-scale, later-life joblessness is here to stay then it is time to debate some
difficult matters: Do we care if some people past 45 have jobs and most do not? If we don't,
then how are we going to find incomes for the many people without earnings? These issues are
beginning to be confronted and debated elsewhere in the developed world. It is time we
addressed them too..."
Source New Zealand Herald 5 August 1999 "When our working lives end at 45" by David Thomson
- THE AMERICAN GULAG
America is becoming "the world's only true gulag", according to Sasha Abramski of
the Independent. Abramski reports that, in the last 20 years, the US prison population has risen
by 566 per cent, from 300,000 inmates in 1981 to nearly 2 million today. President Clinton's
"three strikes and you're out" law means that even the pettiest criminals can find themselves
incarcerated for life.
This rise in prison population is unprecedented in a democratic society. It leaves the United
States far outstripping other developed countries in its rates of imprisonment 645 detainees
per 100,000 of population, which is 6-10 times higher than that of the countries in the
Le Monde Diplomatique observes that the US prison system "makes a direct contribution
to regulating the lower segments of the labour market". It quotes US researchers Bruce Western
and Katherine Beckett's research showing that, during the 1990s, the prison population has meant
that the US unemployment rate has been under-reported by as much as 2 percentage points.
Source The Independent magazine 15 May 1999 quoted in The Week "America: the world's new gulag?" by
Sasha Sabramski; Le Monde Diplomatique July 1998 "Imprisoning the American Poor" by Loic Wacquant; Bruce Western
and Katherine Beckett "How unregulated is the US Labour Market? The Penal system as a Labour Market Institution",
American Sociological Association 1997
- JAPANESE PUBLIC WORKS
Japan may have an unemployment rate as low as 4.4%, but this is also disguised by the
fact that a large number of Japanese unemployed have been absorbed by public works. Japan is
still suffering its worst recession since World War II, although conditions have stopped
deteriorating. The Japanese newspaper Nihon Keizai Shimbun
reports that, as part of the Japanese government's massive spending on job creation, one tenth of the manual labour force has been
absorbed into the building and transport sectors which are heavily subsidised by the state. And this year
the Japanese government has pledged to create another 700,000 jobs in the telecommunications,
IT, tourism and public housing areas.
Nihon Keizai Shimbun says that the result of all this public works has been to distort not only
the Japanese economy, but also its politics. It says that the construction industry is now so
dependent on the public sector that it has become a major political player in its own right: any party
promising to increase government spending is guaranteed its considerable support. The paper
observes that all this "intervention" is not solving unemployment in Japan ... which is still predicted to
rise to 7%.
Source _ Nihon Keizai Shimbun 10 April 1999 (quoted in The Week) "Why the economy is still in trouble"
Top of Page
This Letter's Main Page
The Jobs Letter Home Page |
The Website Home Page
The Jobs Research Trust -- a not-for-profit Charitable Trust
constituted in 1994
We publish The Jobs Letter