Winz -- Select Committee Concerns
from The Jobs Letter No.104 / 3 August 1999
IN THE MIDST of the Winz media feeding frenzy, the PARLIAMENTARY SOCIAL
SERVICES SELECT COMMITTEE released its report on the 1999/2000 Winz estimates. In the report,
the committee listed a number of "serious concerns" about the running of the department. Some
- ON THE MERGER
The integration has encountered some difficulties in the initial phase but the department is
well ahead of schedule with the merger of former Income Support and NZES sites. Sixty- four
sites have been integrated to date and it is expected that 71 more sites will be integrated by 1
October 1999. This will leave approximately 10 remaining sites to be integrated.
A total of 113 staff have been made redundant as a result of the merger. This included 42
managers, 53 frontline and frontline support staff and 18 corporate staff.
- ON CUSTOMER SERVICE
While we believe that personalized customer service is a good concept, we are concerned at
the high level of case-manager turnover. This can work to undermine some of the major benefits
that result from the case-manager model. Another problem that can result from this model is a lack
of flexibility in the service. Customers can experience difficulties in receiving satisfactory
service when their own case-manager is not available due to illness or for other reasons.
Anecdotal evidence suggests that there have been a number of problems in the area of
customer service within Winz, particularly since the integration. This was greatly exacerbated early in
1999 when Winz took over the processing of student allowances. The type of problems that appear
to have been occurring routinely have included lost files and/or parts of files, long waiting times
at call centres and customers receiving conflicting information from different staff members.
Winz deals with a large number of clients with a range of different needs and it is inevitable
that there will be some human error. However, we are concerned about the high level of error
that seems to be occurring in the organisation. We urge Winz to address these issues and look at
ways to minimise these problems.
- ON STAFF CASELOADS
We have had concerns in the past about the average level of caseload staff have been carrying
and asked if this issue had been addressed in the new department. The department stated
that caseloads are dropping across the country although there is some regional variation in this.
In some regions the case-load average has decreased to around 195 clients per staff member and
the department feels that this is a realistic level for all regions to aim at in the short-term.
The quality of the service delivered by Winz rests largely on the quality of the staff and the
level of training they receive. We therefore stress the need for WINZ to address the issue of
reducing case-load levels over the next year.
- ON THE CHILDCARE SUBSIDY
We are concerned about one particular issue that has arisen concerning the administration of
the childcare subsidy. Winz pays the subsidy directly to the parents who are then required to pay
the child-care centre. This has the potential to lead to overpayments if, for example, the child
cannot attend the child-care centre due to illness. The onus is then on the parents to repay Winz and
this can lead to an accumulation of debt owing to Winz from parents. We encourage Winz to
explore other ways of administering this scheme to avoid difficulties that could arise in this area.
- ON DEBT RECOVERY
A performance standard of $177 million has been established as the target for recovery of
current debt. Current debt is classified as debt belonging to people who are currently receiving a
benefit from Winz. It includes both fraudulent and non-fraudulent debt, including overpayment as a
result of departmental error. The department told us that this figure is based upon historical
collection performance and forecast impacts which may influence current debt recoveries during
1999/2000. The purpose of a debt recovery standard is to ensure a focus is maintained on Crown debt
The department records fraudulent and non-fraudulent debts separately, but does not record
the separate amounts recovered because customer's debts are aggregated when collected. We
have urged the department in the past to consider recording these two categories separately because
it has been misleading in terms of the public perception that all of this debt is the result of
benefit fraud. We again encourage the department to consider separating these categories.
- Committee members are MPs Joy Quigley (chairperson); Gerry Brownlee (Deputy
Chairperson); Arthur Anae, Rev Ann Batten, Lianne Dalziel, Taito Philip Field, Laila Harre,
Steve Maharey, Dr Muriel Newman and Tony Steel.
Source - Report of the Social Services Committee 1999/2000 Estimates Vote Work and Income
Top of Page
This Letter's Main Page
The Jobs Letter Home Page |
The Website Home Page
The Jobs Research Trust -- a not-for-profit Charitable Trust
constituted in 1994
We publish The Jobs Letter